5 Best Catchers Mitts: Reviews & Buying Guide

The best catchers mitts are equipment that every baseball player must possess, from major leaguer to little league pitcher. However, some people – even those who are playing as catchers – often overlook the importance of having a decent mitt on their hands. 

These mitts are like your second skin and should be treated as such. If you get a good piece of mitt (no pun intended), you will be able to handle flying balls and catch them with appropriate precision. Oppositely, a bad mitt can stifle your game and will make you feel awkward and unprotected. 

If you want a high-quality baseball mitt for catchers, then the following list is an excellent place to start.

ImageGloveSizeMaterial
Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball/Softball Glove Series 33 inchesSynthetic leather
Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Catcher's Mitt 32.5 inchesFull-grain pigskin leather
Wilson A500 Catcher's Mitt 32 inches Top-grain leather
Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove Series 34 inchesFull-grain leather
Easton Professional Hybrid Baseball Glove Series 33.5 inchesHorween steer hide / Professional Reserve steer hide

5 Best Catchers Mitts

1. Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball/Softball Glove Series

It’s not a surprise that a Rawlings product gets into this rundown. After all, it is a reputable manufacturer of professionally tailored baseball and softball gloves. Its Player Preferred Baseball Mitt is a suitable choice for catchers who want to have a reliable mitt. It has a size of 33 inches, which ensures its scope and range. The mitt features the proprietary Zero Shock palm padding that negates impact coming from solidly thrown balls. Moreover, the mitt has a quick break-in process, ensuring that it’s game-ready. 

The back of this mitt has a conventional design, which, in turn, improves its fit. With its single solid web pattern, you can guarantee that it can help you catch and seize any incoming ball. This Rawlings baseball mitt is available in both right-hand and left-hand orientations. However, keep in mind that it is only made from synthetic leather and not an authentic one.

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS:

  • Size – 33 inches
  • Web – 1-piece closed web
  • Material – Synthetic leather
  • Orientation – Left-hand / right-hand
  • Weight – 1.37 pounds
Pros
  • Quick break-in construction
  • Features closed webbing
  • Comes with impact-absorbing padding
Cons
  • Not tailored from genuine leather

2. Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Catcher’s Mitt

You should also consider the Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Catcher’s Mitt, especially if you have players who want to experience wearing responsive, easy-to-break-in mitts. This unit features a ButterSoft palm liner which makes it durable and ultra-comfortable when worn. It also increases the feel when catching balls, making this baseball mitt an exceptional tool during competitive leagues and practices. This mitt also has minimal laces on its web to optimize its flexibility in its closing axis. 

Meanwhile, the patented Parashock Palm Pad ensures that you can catch balls without dealing much of their impact. This added layer of protection ensures that you can play to your heart’s content without worries about potential strains and injuries. In addition, the PowerClose technology integrated on this mitt enables young players to have more control, allowing them to catch with accuracy and responsiveness.

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS:

  • Size – 32.5 inches
  • Web – Half-moon
  • Material – Full-grain pigskin leather
  • Orientation – Left-hand / right-hand
  • Weight – 3 pounds
Pros
  • Provides exceptional feel to its wearer
  • Equipped with various protective technologies
  • Comes with a secure fit
Cons
  • Smaller than most of its counterparts with the same size

3. Wilson A500 Catcher’s Mitt

Surely enough, highly reputable baseball brands like Wilson have their opuses regarding mitts for baseball catchers. The A500 of Wilson is proof of that. This all-leather catcher’s mitt features a half-moon webbing for enhanced stability and flexibility. Its black / copper top-grain leather is oozing with its presence and performance. The material is rigid and can last for a long time, even if the mitt is used constantly. At the same time, this baseball utility is lightweight, making it an excellent choice for youth players

The absence of unnecessary bulk and weight ensures that you won’t feel burdened by this mitt. Furthermore, its double palm construction ensures that your hands are fully protected. With this mitt, players can just pour their focus on the game without distractions. But at the same time, let me remind you that this mitt requires some breaking in. Some baseball glove oil can help do the trick. 

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS:

  • Size – 32 inches
  • Web – Half-moon
  • Material – Top-grain leather
  • Orientation – Left-hand / right-hand
  • Weight – 1.21 pounds
Pros
  • Designed to last for a long time
  • It offers a great and snugly fit for youth players
  • Absorbs impacts effectively
Cons
  • Requires extensive break-in process

4. Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove Series

Those who are searching for a competition-ready catcher’s mitt should check the Rawlings Liberty. Sizing at 34 inches, this mitt works well with youth players to adults. It features a modified H-web construction with a pull strap for guaranteed grip and security when catching balls. Needless to say, this mitt has a superb authentic leather construction. This utility is highly durable and offers an excellent feel and responsiveness. In fact, this mitt makes you think that you are scooping balls with your bare hands – minus the impact and pain. 

With its balanced patterns and adjustable hand opening, the Rawlins Liberty gives its players the custom fit and control that they need. Moreover, this baseball/softball glove has Poron XRD pads on its index and palm. These pads can almost nullify the ball’s impact, ensuring that you have enough protection and control when catching balls. Again, this unit has a game-ready architecture, as its leather has been oil-treated at the factory. 

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS:

  • Size – 34 inches
  • Web – Pro H-web
  • Material – Full-grain leather
  • Orientation – Left-hand / right-hand
  • Weight – 2 pounds
Pros
  • Provides exceptional protection to the hands
  • Ensures adjustable fit with its pull-strap
  • Oil-treated leather reduces break-in required
Cons
  • No significant drawbacks

5. Easton Professional Hybrid Baseball Glove Series

The Easton Professional Hybrid Baseball Glove Series is a coveted baseball glove series. It is a stack of professionally constructed gloves for infielders, outfielders, and catchers. Its catcher’s mitt, specifically, is a work of art. It features a hybrid infrastructure, as proven by its USA-made chrome-tanned Horween steer hide leather lining and palm. This unique tailoring has been amalgamated with a lightweight shell back made from Japanese Professional Reserve steer hide. In a nutshell, this mitt is not just tough but brims with comfort and flexibility.

Its one-piece solid web pattern guarantees that it is a catcher’s mitt that even league players would want to consider. It even boasts high-quality rawhide laces that ensure that the mitt’s pocket is not just deep but durable, too. Of course, this baseball utility has a game-ready construction. It doesn’t need a stressful break-in. Fresh from the package, you can already play with this one. 

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS:

  • Size – 33.5 inches
  • Web – 1-piece solid web
  • Material – Horween steer hide / Professional Reserve steer hide
  • Orientation – Left-hand / right-hand
  • Weight – 2 pounds
Pros
  • Sophisticated all-leather construction
  • Provides the soft but tacky feel
  • Optimized for catching speeding and hard-hitting balls
Cons
  • No significant drawbacks

How To Choose The Best Catchers Mitts

How To Choose The Best Catchers Mitts

As every baseball fan knows, the catcher’s mitt is an essential baseball gear that every catcher of every level uses. If you are using a mitt that makes you feel comfortable and is suitable for your level of play, you will be able to perform your best while catching. Conversely, if your mitt is uncomfortable and not good enough for you, you will most likely injure yourself or, worse, lose your concentration while catching.

Because of these repercussions, you would want to make sure that you are wearing the right mitt. But how do you assess if a particular baseball glove is a match made in heaven for you? 

The following considerations should help you narrow your choices. 

Sizing

Size is an important aspect when it comes to choosing a baseball or softball glove. You would want to have the right fit or something that is not too small or too large. 

In the context of catcher’s mitts, it is vital that it gives you extended reach to expand your catching range. Basically, it is notable that mitts worn by catchers are significantly bigger than other positions. Most infield and outfield positions have sizes that only extend up to 13 inches. The story is different when it comes to catcher’s gloves.

The table below will give you a clear picture of the ideal size of the mitt based on the player’s age. 

Age Size
Under 7 years old29.5 inches to 30 inches
8 – 10 years old30 inches to 31 inches
11 – 13 years old30 inches to 32.5 inches
Over 14 years old32 inches to 34.5 inches

Of course, it is still necessary that you or your player can try the mitt itself. The table above only provides you with the ideal estimates. All of us have different hand sizes. For instance, some kids have large hands, while some adult baseball players don’t have a burly constitution. Hence, it is best that you can do some trials so that you can arrive at the mitt that matches your preferences.

Web Patterns 

You should also check the web pattern integrated into the glove. On the surface, the web might just appear as an added aesthetics to the glove. Of course, the part that the webs make the gloves look fantastic is not wrong. However, these webs have been integrated into these mitts to add specific benefits and advantages. The kind of perk that you can get from them actually depends on how the webs were tailored. 

For catchers, the following web constructions are the most recommended:

  • One-piece – This particular web pattern showcases a single piece of leather with laces on its outer edges. It gives the mitt a tight and semi-shallow pocket that can help you catch and secure balls. 
  • Half-moon – A half-moon web is also a popular choice for a catcher’s mitt. It has two leather straps that have been laced together, which is pretty similar to the style of two-piece webs in various fielders gloves. With such a design, the glove attains a tight and secure pocket. It also improves the overall flexibility of the mitt.
  • Modified H-web – Typically, a modified H-web pattern is designed for first baseman. But it can also be incorporated into the catcher’s glove. Instead of the simple H-shape leather construction, another leather strap is being affixed on the top. With this construction, a player’s catching radius increases.

Material 

There are a number of materials used in the construction of baseball gloves. The choice for the glove material actually depends on your needs and preferences. But if I were you, I would choose a glove constructed from a material that can help improve or solidify my skill level. Of course, you should never ignore the issue of durability here. 

Here are some of the common materials used on baseball gloves.

  • Pro Series of premium leathers – If you want the best right from the get-go, you should get catcher’s mitts that are made from these leathers. They possess exceptional quality. They are pretty peerless when it comes to comfort and durability. Their craftsmanship is impeccable, too, which allows them to conform to their users’ hands.
  • Oil-treated or generic leather – This option is suitable for players who are planning to scale up to higher leagues. These oil-treated options are soft and have been factory-broken to ensure that they have a game-ready performance. 
  • Synthetic leather – A synthetic leather is technically not genuine leather. But it has properties that are akin to leather. Most of the time, these leathers don’t require a break-in process. They are also lightweight, which makes them suitable for young players. 

In Summary

You have to secure the best catchers mitts if you want to guarantee that you’ll remain comfortable and protected while catching balls. It’s a piece of no-brainer information, but I have to rub it well to ensure that you won’t settle for less. The job of a catcher is not that laidback, after all. Strength, flexibility, and physical endurance are necessary for them to execute their tasks. And an excellent baseball mitt can help them perform their role without getting dislodged from their game.

That’s it for the meantime. If you have other related inquiries, feel free to drop them in the comment section below.

Leave a Comment